Writes Jeff Johnson on a totally unrelated matter, but with awesome prescience:
Apple finally released Mac OS X 10.5, code named “Leopard”, followed soon thereafter by Mac OS X 10.5.1, code named “Oops”.
Leopard is a release that’s got it together in most places. However, it’s the biggest Mac OS X upgrade ever, and it was subject to a humiliating delay (or several, depending on how you count or if your last name is Thurrott), which means that it’s been harder than before to coordinate everything to work exactly as planned on the release day.
However, Spotlight is in such a state of disarray that I’m honestly wondering if they thought they could pull off a rewrite of the UI but had to abandon ship and patch things together before shipping it.
Not only can you only search certain sub-folders of “This Mac”, excluding potentially interesting (and potentially annoying) preference files (update: patently false; check that article again), you can’t actually choose folders to the same extent that you did in Tiger. In Tiger you could click “Other” and bring up a list to which you could persistently add your favorite folders and check the folders to search this time around. In Leopard… it’s either “This Mac” or the folder or volume you had selected or are positioned in. And gaming it is not an option – if you have two or more volumes or folders selected, or if you’re in a location that can’t be searched (the Trash), it falls back to This Mac.
The results are also abysmal. I’m not sure if anyone liked the Spotlight grouped view from Tiger (it had strange selection retention problems on queries that hadn’t finished or that kept re-running, in my experience) but the list view, or the list portion of the Cover Flow view, is certainly worse than in Tiger. You get three columns (Name, Kind and Last Opened) and no way to change them, making searches for file size, any date but Last Opened or in fact any other piece of metadata a thoroughly useless exercise. In fact, no view options appear whatsoever in any mode, except for the omnipresent option to Always Open that particular search or Smart Folder in that mode. Gee, thanks.
What’s most annoying about this is that Spotlight is fast in Leopard. Spotlight was slow and crash-prone in Tiger, no matter which of my Macs or which hard drive, and no matter how many times I reset the indices and started over. Someone cleaned out the hybrid maple syrup / motor oil gunk out of Spotlight’s kernel pipelines, and now regular use is severely hampered.
Here’s hoping for Mac OS X 10.5.2, “Restored Prowling”.